Tuesday, December 10, 2019

Dems Issue Their Articles of Impeachment

You can read the articles of impeachment at this link. (See also this more general news article). There are two articles of impeachment. The first alleges an abuse of power by soliciting Ukraine to investigate Joe Biden and whether Ukraine interfered with the 2016 Election, and that these requests to Ukraine were made for the purpose of assisting Trump's reelection bid in 2020. The second alleges an obstruction of Congress by instructing administration officials to not respond to subpoenas issued as part of its impeachment investigation in derogation of the Congress' power to impeach.

    If you read the transcript of Pres. Trump's conversation with the Ukrainian president, you can see that it pertains to whether Biden had engaged in a quid-pro-quo with Ukraine to shut down an investigation into Hunter Biden and Burisma--something that Biden had bragged about on video (which is also raised in the discussion)--so Biden is going to be the subject of the impeachment proceeding once it reaches the Senate. The issue will not be whether the President made the request, but whether it was proper, which will segue into a more general discussion of equality under the law and whether some animals are more equal than others.

    As for the second article, that, too, will turn into a joke because past presidents and their officials repeatedly ignored Congressional subpoenas. As The Economist noted in a May 2019 article, "Donald Trump is not the first president to fight subpoenas." The article notes for instance:
In October 2011 Eric Holder, Barack Obama’s attorney-general, received a congressional subpoena. Mr Obama tried to block it by declaring executive privilege, in June 2012. A court rejected Mr Obama’s blanket claim of privilege, but not until January 2016.
(See also "9 Times The Obama Administration Fought Subpoenas or Blocked Officials from Testifying Before Congress"--PJ Media; "Subpoena fight over operation Fast and Furious documents finally settled"--Politico).  Trying to distinguish this case because it related to an impeachment investigation will only encourage more impeachment investigations in the future.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Chicago's Gun Control In Action: Automatic Weapons Fire

I think the saying that "when guns are outlawed, only criminals will own guns" has finally moved from a truism to an axiom. Chicag...