Yesterday's Gates of Vienna linked to the following Fox News article: "Masked dirt bike riders swarm SUV in brazen NYC street attack, sparking police crackdown." The article relates:
New York City officials are warning a group of masked dirt bike riders that arrests could be imminent after video captured a chaotic confrontation in which several riders surrounded and attacked a vehicle on a busy Staten Island street.
The crackdown follows a Wednesday incident on Richmond Avenue in Staten Island's Bulls Head neighborhood, where video showed several masked riders swarming a white SUV stopped at a traffic light.
In the video obtained by Fox News Digital, several individuals [ed: black teens] appeared to kick and strike the vehicle, while another appeared to throw an object at it. As the driver attempted to leave, the SUV appeared to run over a dirt bike that had been positioned in front of the vehicle.
During a news conference Thursday, NYPD Assistant Chief John Buttacavoli warned those involved that police were gathering intelligence and working to identify the suspects.
"We know who you are, and you will be getting a knock on your door very soon," Buttacavoli said, emphasizing that the behavior had escalated from a quality-of-life concern into criminal activity.
It's New York City, so the perpetrators will never face any real consequences for their actions and they know it. The disturbing point is that this does not appear to be a one-time incident, but a recurrent practice among feral teens in that area.
I was originally going to point to this incident as an example of why when driving you might want to carry a weapon with a high magazine capacity since you will be dealing with many attackers.
At this point, I will insert my usual disclaimer: I am not your attorney and this is not legal advice.
But this situation also seems to show a gray area in self-defense law. It is true that the teens were intent on damaging the vehicle and terrorizing the occupants, but they seemed to know better than to actually break a window where it could be viewed as an assault or battery that might justify lethal force. We saw something similar back in 2020's "summer of love" where protestors would surround a car and start beating on it, but the poor occupant would later face charges if they tried to get away by driving through the protestors, or if they displayed a weapon to get the protestors to back away. The reasoning in such cases seemed to be that although the car might be damaged, the occupants were not themselves in imminent danger of serious bodily injury.
There is no indication in the news story that the driver of the SUV was facing charges for driving over the motorcycle that had been placed to block his or her way, but it probably would have been a very different situation if someone had been seated on the bike or standing directly behind it.
What would you have done differently, if anything, from the driver caught in this situation?
No comments:
Post a Comment