Monday, November 16, 2026

Pinochet and Banned Books

My children have always loved books. And so most every weekend finds us trundling off to a bookstore. Over the past few years, we are often met with some sign or display at the entrance warning about "banned" books or displaying books for sale that are supposedly "banned"--which begs the question of how they are able to offer them for sale if they are actually banned.

    As always, however, the Left is being deceptive. By "banned" the Left means books, generally pornographic in nature, that some school district or public library determined was unsuitable for children to read. They, speaking of the Left, have no problem banning books that are written by conservative authors, paint white people in a positive light, or appeal to heritage Americans. 

    For instance, Mark Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (published in 1885) is one of the most frequently banned and challenged books in U.S. history. (See also here). And who can forget in 2009 when libraries and used book stores began the wholesale destruction of older children's books over the excuse that lead had been used in the ink. 

    Another example: Mark Dice recently published a book entitled The Cultural War which promptly shot up to #10 on Amazon ... and then was shadow banned (which the author discusses in this video). 

    Sometimes we have seen authors "cancelled" due to conservative views. For instance, popular science-fiction and fantasy author Orson Scott Card was "cancelled" due his taking positions against homosexuality, gay marriage, and crimes against children. Jon Del Arroz's article "Mainstream Science Fiction Never Recovered After Canceling Orson Scott Card For Standing For Christian Values," notes:

Orson Scott Card was one of the most celebrated figures in science fiction, with his work Ender’s Game and Speaker For The Dead revered as some of the greatest classics in science fiction, it’s odd how he’s all but disappeared from mainstream publishing, but it’s because he was canceled for advocating for Christian values.

Even J.K. Rawling--author of the Harry Potter books, and who could hardly be described as conservative--nevertheless has faced strong criticism and backlash about her views on transgenderism and men pretending to be women. 

    Sometimes an author needn't even be conservative, but merely take an unpopular view. In my 2024 post "Things We Aren't Allowed To Talk About," I'd noted the long campaign to cancel the author Roald Dahl because he had dared criticize Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon; and in 2023, Puffin Books announced it was revising some of Dahl's most famous works to remove certain harmful language, even going so far as to automatically update ebooks that had already been published and distributed without any warning or consent of those that purchased the books.

    And then there are those books that touch upon topics so forbidden we are not even allowed to think about them: "Booksellers remove racist and Holocaust denial titles from their websites"--The Guardian. Which is ironic given that one of the primary complaints against the National Socialists was that they burned books.

    But this ... finally ... brings me to the article that prompted this post: "Pinochet LIVES! Lost Books Recovered!" from Anarchonomicon, wherein the author describes his or her quest to track down copies of Augusto Pinochet's memoir. The author begins by noting commonly banned or censored books and topics:

    When I created the “Anarchonomicon Real Banned Book List” (5th Edition coming soon!), there were several Immediate rabbit holes to go down in follow up posts….

    The first Rabbit hole, of course, was how Holocaust “revisionism”, and Holocaust revisionism alone, immediately jumps out as the ONLY major issue of historical debate and political struggle, to both be heavily censored out of a claimed moral concern (something not done for works either denying or hyper-inflating the deaths of Stalin, or Mao, or American Empire), to the point that “Holocaust Denial” and only “Holocaust Denial” is a crime of historical belief in Europe, Russia, and the Anglo-sphere.

    And yet despite that there are hundreds of books (See the full revisionist Bibliography at the Institute of Historical Review), many by people formerly of high academic esteem, attacking and pulling threads on this one historical narrative. Again there is nothing of the Sort even for works such as the crimes of Lenin or Stalin, which you’d think would be comparable.

    This unique, literally religious, significance of the Holocaust ( “Holocaust Theology” is something you can get a PhD and Tenure in) immediately jumps out at you once you start assembling lists of banned books.

 [snip]

    The most interesting Rabbit hole on the Real banned book list, at least by my estimation, was the the subject of Political Science Professor, General, and Military Dictator of Chile: Augusto Pinochet, and the seemingly complete disappearance of his books, both in Spanish, and in their official English Translation.

[snip]

    Thousands of English Copies of Augusto Pinochet’s 4 Volume memoirs “A Journey through a Life” had been printed… And seemingly completely disappeared.

    Such that even discovering such books had ever existed were an extraordinary challenge in 2024.

The author did eventually track down a genuine English translation of the first volume of the memoirs and machine translations of the remaining three volumes, providing links to PDFs of those books at the bottom of his/her article. But the real issue is why and how the books had so completely disappeared:

    So I knew what had happened to Pinochet’s memoirs… across South American, American, Canadian, British, and seemingly the entire university system… Communists of the more daring sort had stollen and dumpstered them, but even more commonly Left-leaning librarians, one at a time had quietly ‘mislabelled’ the books, and then thrown them in a pile of books for shredding.

    No group people have ever destroyed more books than librarians. Like school teachers, they’re one of those nice sounding groups of people, til you apply any scrutiny and realize they’re all ideologically captured, exist largely to destroy the thing you’d naively think they exist to protect and, in my moderate conservative opinion, deserve to be lined up and shot to the last.

    You should be trolling and buying up things at bookstores if you ever want to hold onto a work… Somehow my local library today has entire aisles of Monster fucker erotica, yet all the local history books that I remember occupying shelves when I was a kid… All the nice old regimental histories that had been there since the local regiments themselves had donated the copies in the 1950s? Gone. Not even on the library interloan system… I have to troll thrift stores located in barns to find a former library copy (with the library card slot still glued to the inside of the cover) of a Gilded hardcover history of the Grey-Simcoe Foresters or the Lincoln and Welland Regiment… With a “For Destruction” stamped on the first page.

Read the whole thing. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

American Rifleman: What Should Future Ruger Revolvers Look Like?

A couple of weeks ago, I had published a post entitled " What Could The Future Hold For Ruger Revolvers? " I noted that Ruger had ...