VIDEO: 3 O'clock vs. Appendix vs. Hip Carry Positions

The producer of the video, below, makes the argument that the best position for a concealed carry holster (at least around the waist--he doesn't really address other methods of carry) is the 3 o'clock position even when compared to appendix or what he terms "hip carry"--i.e., 4 or 5 o'clock position. He doesn't discuss cross-draw positions (10 or 11 o'clock) and only mentions center of the back.

    I think he makes good points about why 3 o'clock works for him. But rather than viewers getting defensive that his favorite carry position is not mentioned or rejected by the producer, I think this video is a good opportunity to (a) listen to a different point of view on the topic, and (b) consider that what is the best, or even what is acceptable, is going to vary between people--sometimes, significantly so. Often times, the type of clothing that must be used or other factors (i.e., how much sitting, standing, etc.) must be considered. Also, realize that sometimes the issue may not be the carry position, but the holster and/or weapon. 

    For instance, although the producer of the video did not like appendix, would that have changed with a different holster that allowed him to adjust how deep the holster rode in relation to the belt, or that allowed for the attachment of pads or wedges to fine tune the orientation of the holster? Would a different sized weapon have made a difference?

    The producer of the video favors 3 o'clock, but the only other alternative he discusses in any great depth is carrying at 5 o'clock which is almost a small of the back type of carry. Myself, because of my body shape, tend to prefer the 4 o'clock or 2 o'clock (if I can get away with it--it does get in the way of fishing things out of your front pocket) because the 3 o'clock position is too visible in my opinion. I've also used a cross-draw holster with good success and it is a good carry position if you are sitting or driving. I've tried appendix with a couple different pistols, but haven't really liked it--but I've only used cheap holsters and recognize that it might be more comfortable with a better holster.  

    I've noted before that the small of the back carry is one of the worst carry methods--unless you are someone like a store clerk who stands all day and can get away with wearing a jacket, a vest, or untucked shirt. Then it is comfortable and allows reasonably quick access. You just have to be careful to not bend over at the waist because it will either expose the weapon by your clothing riding up or cause the weapon to print as the clothing becomes more taut over the weapon. Squat down keeping your back as straight as possible if you need to pick something up off the floor.

     My main point is that just because something works well (or doesn't work well) for one person--even if that is someone you trust and respect--doesn't mean that it will be the best option for you and your life style. But I'm also not suggesting that you completely disregard information from the best people. But you may need to consider other view points and experiment yourself. That is why, when the topic of holsters comes up, you will discover that most gun people will have a substantial number of holsters in boxes or whatnot that they have tried and then discarded as they found something better or newer. They may even have multiple holsters for the same firearm to accommodate different carrying needs and circumstances. 

    Anyway, even though I don't prefer the 3 o'clock for my carrying, the producer raises some good points, so be sure to watch the video.

 VIDEO: "3:00 VS Appendix VS Hip Carry"
EscapeFromNewYork (8 min.)